embed embed share link link comment comment
Embed This Video close
Share This Video close
bookmark bookmark bookmark bookmark bookmark bookmark bookmark bookmark bookmark bookmark bookmark bookmark
embed test
Rate This Video embed
Tags For This Video tags
rate rate tags tags related related lights lights

4. The p-Zombie

4. The p-Zombie

Zombies have infected (ahem) our liberal arts and sciences as well as our hearts. In the field of philosophy, for example, they have the concept of the p-zombie. What is a p-zombie? Well, it doesn’t necessarily run, which is a good thing but it also doesn’t necessarily consume the flesh of human beings, which leaves me wondering.

A p-zombie is a lot more like the zombies of Haitian folklore in that it is a human being without a consciousness, they would behave exactly like a person but would not, in fact, be a person because it wouldn’t be conscious. It would act but it wouldn’t know what it was doing, why it was doing it or have any particular violation.

More specifically,

A philosophical zombie (p-zombie, for short) would be a human body without consciousness which would nevertheless behave like a human body with consciousness. To some philosophers (e.g., Daniel Dennett) this is a contradictory notion and thus an impossible conception. If it behaves like a person and is indistinguishable from a person, then it is a person. Other philosophers (e.g. Todd Moody and David Chalmers) argue that a p-zombie would be distinguishable from a person even though indistinguishable from a conscious person. It is distinguishable, say these philosophers, because it is stipulated that it is not conscious even though it is indistinguishable from a conscious being. In case you are wondering why philosophers would debate whether it is possible to conceive of a p-zombie, it is because some philosophers do not believe or do not want to believe that consciousness can be reduced to a set of materialistic functions.

You might be wondering whether you should run from p-zombies, well, that’s where things get tricky. As skepdic’s notes, a p-zombie would be completely indistinguishable from a person. They would walk, talk and shamble just like the rest of us. As a result, it’s possible that you could be in contact with p-zombies as we speak.

You, in fact, could be a p-zombie.

Though to put your mind at ease, I hear that the most common place for p-zombies to turn up is within graduate courses of philosophy colleges and apparently a feature film to come out sometime this year, go figure.

Related Posts

For free updates about all of our new content, you should follow us on twitter today. You can also join us on our Facebook Fan Page.

Products You Might Like


Now Playing

Sponsors